tell me somethin' good
February 07, 2007
Back when I was actively researching and writing Gothic, I read at least a dozen stories about moms who killed their kids. Each and every one broke my heart.
It wasn't the deaths of the kids that did it, even though that is certainly very, very sad. What got me was how similar each case was, how there was almost a template that you could fill out. Isolated (either in terms of physical proximity of other people or in terms of emotional proximity of same) mom who has had previous (if undiagnosed) bouts with mental illness finds herself talking to "Jesus" or "Satan" or "God" who tells her to kill her kids because they are evil. Because there is either no one else around for days on end or who is able to see that mom has gone right off the rails and is willing to open their god damn mouths about it, mom kills the kids in some kid of horrific, bloody way where the kids in question knew what was going on as it was going on. That's what gets me -- the one person who was the constant in these kids' lives -- because, clearly, there was no one else around who was willing to be responsible or, if that was too hard, present and engaged in some minor way -- is the one who causes them such fear and pain. I can't help but imagine what those kids' faces looked like. That's what gets me, every single time.
And, sadly, it has happened again.
Part of me wants to write a book about moms who kill. There are lots of moms to choose from, certainly. But, apart from a few details, the stories wouldn't change, which would make for a really boring book.
Besides, spending months on end of having to research these stories and talk to the moms would completely blow my liquor budget and probably lead to a not inconsequential drug habit.
Something good? My kitties are really cute.
Posted by: Trishwah | February 07, 2007 at 05:30 PM
Reading about the kids fighting back always gets me.
Examining the cultural reasons behind the similarities would be interesting. Maybe an article or series of interviews instead of a book?
Almost everything I've ever read or watched about these tragedies reeks of sensationalism. (The cop talking about "evil" in the linked to piece, for example.)
Posted by: karrie | February 07, 2007 at 05:59 PM
The stores are filled with valentine's day chocolate. I think that's something good.
Strangely, my darkest thoughts were because my child was perfect and would be ruined by the world (okay by me). I think Andrea Yates's voices told her that she needed to protect her kids from sin. Interesting dichotomy.
Posted by: Netter | February 08, 2007 at 08:33 AM
And then you have this:
http://www.cnn.com/2007/US/02/08/toddler.death.ap/index.html
WTH, people??? Tragic.
Something good: Burdick Valentine's Day assortments are available.
Posted by: karrie | February 08, 2007 at 01:10 PM
Twish - your kitties are pretty cute. Well, one of 'em is. I'll have to take your word on the other one because he didn't deign to spend any time with me. My kitties are fat and warm, which is good right now.
Karrie - Mmmmmm...Burdicks. Must not order online. Must. not. that does cheer me up. The CNN story does not. And, yes, I've thought about doing a longer Harpers'-like feature but a) don't know who would buy it and b) don't know if I would make it through the researching with my psyche intact. it's a selfish reason -- but a reason nonetheless. Still, I'm tempted to try to do *something* to change the way the dialog is framed -- the whole "evil" v. "ill" thing.
Netter -- I just ate a handful of red, white and pink M&Ms. There is some good out there. I don't think your darkest thoughts (and Yates') are all that strange. The whole idea of protecting the kids from some sort of intangible evil is pretty common. It's just weird that it always seems to be couched in religious language. Glad you didn't do it, tho. Did it ever reach a point where someone had to intervene? And if you mind my asking -- don't answer. :)
Posted by: Adrienne | February 08, 2007 at 01:34 PM
I have a new puppy. That's something good!
Posted by: PL | February 08, 2007 at 03:05 PM
No one intervened. I was lucid enough that those thoughts by the tub and the thought I should step in front of a bus got me to ask my doc to up the meds.
Posted by: Netter | February 08, 2007 at 03:31 PM